The Smith & Wesson Governor is a versatile and powerful revolver designed to chamber both.410 shotgun shells and.45 Colt cartridges. However, like any complex firearm, it is not immune to issues and criticisms. Owners and enthusiasts have reported various problems with the Governor, ranging from mechanical issues to ammunition compatibility concerns. This article delves into the most commonly reported Smith & Wesson Governor problems, examining the causes, consequences, and potential solutions for each issue.
Key Points
- The Smith & Wesson Governor is prone to ammunition compatibility issues, particularly with certain.410 shotgun shells.
- Cylinder gap and timing problems can lead to inconsistent performance and potential safety hazards.
- Trigger issues, including heavy trigger pull and stacking, have been reported by some users.
- Finish durability and the potential for rust or corrosion are concerns, especially in harsh environments.
- Reliability and maintenance requirements are critical factors for Governor owners, given its unique design and ammunition capabilities.
Ammunition Compatibility Issues

One of the most significant challenges faced by Governor owners is finding ammunition that functions reliably in the revolver. The.410 shotgun shell, in particular, poses compatibility issues due to variations in shell length, powder charge, and projectile type. Some.410 shells may not eject properly or may cause the cylinder to bind, leading to frustrating malfunctions at the range or, more critically, in self-defense situations. Smith & Wesson recommends using specific types of.410 ammunition to minimize these issues, but even with recommended ammo, some problems may persist.
Cylinder Gap and Timing Problems
The cylinder gap—the space between the cylinder and the barrel—can significantly affect the Governor’s performance. A poorly aligned or excessively large cylinder gap can lead to gas leakage, reducing the revolver’s velocity and accuracy. Moreover, timing issues, where the cylinder does not align perfectly with the barrel when the trigger is pulled, can cause the revolver to malfunction. These mechanical issues can be addressed through professional gunsmithing, but they highlight the importance of regular maintenance and inspection for the Governor.
Common Issues | Description | Solution |
---|---|---|
Ammunition Compatibility | Inconsistent performance with certain.410 shells | Use recommended ammunition, ensure proper cylinder maintenance |
Cylinder Gap and Timing | Performance and safety issues due to mechanical misalignment | Professional gunsmithing for adjustment and maintenance |
Trigger Issues | Heavy trigger pull, stacking affecting accuracy and usability | Trigger job by a professional gunsmith, practice and technique refinement |

Trigger Issues and Durability Concerns

Some Governor owners have reported issues with the trigger, including a heavy trigger pull and stacking, where the trigger pull weight increases as the trigger is pulled back. These issues can affect the revolver’s accuracy and make it more challenging to use, especially for those without extensive handgun experience. Additionally, concerns about the durability of the finish and the potential for rust or corrosion, particularly in humid or salty environments, underscore the need for rigorous maintenance and storage practices.
Reliability and Maintenance
The reliability of the Governor is closely tied to its maintenance. Given its complexity and the variety of ammunition it can chamber, regular cleaning, inspection, and potential adjustment by a professional gunsmith are essential. Owners must be diligent about checking for wear on critical components, ensuring the cylinder gap is within specifications, and verifying that the trigger mechanism is functioning smoothly. By prioritizing maintenance and being mindful of the Governor’s unique characteristics, owners can maximize its performance and longevity.
What types of.410 shells are recommended for the Smith & Wesson Governor?
+Smith & Wesson recommends using.410 shells with a 2.5" or 3" length, and a payload that does not exceed the revolver's design specifications. It's also advisable to consult the owner's manual or contact Smith & Wesson directly for the most current recommendations.
How often should I clean and maintain my Governor?
+Regular maintenance is key to the Governor's reliability. After every use, the revolver should be thoroughly cleaned, with special attention to the cylinder and barrel. Additionally, it's recommended to have a professional gunsmith inspect and service the Governor annually or as needed based on usage.
Can I use the Governor for both target shooting and self-defense?
+Yes, the Governor's versatility makes it suitable for both target shooting and self-defense. However, it's crucial to choose the appropriate ammunition for the intended use and to ensure the revolver is properly maintained and functioning reliably.
In conclusion, while the Smith & Wesson Governor offers unparalleled versatility and power, it also presents unique challenges and requirements for its owners. By understanding the common issues associated with the Governor, such as ammunition compatibility, mechanical problems, and maintenance needs, owners can better appreciate the importance of proper care, use, and maintenance. With the right approach, the Governor can be a trusted and reliable companion for a wide range of shooting applications.